Nigerian banks have invested heavily in firewalls and Network Access Control (NAC). However, few instruments test whether these controls work, and fewer are validated or benchmarked against recognised standards. This paper therefore specifies how a composite framework that scores firewall and NAC effectiveness will be implemented, validated, and benchmarked. The study adopts a pragmatic, convergent mixed-methods design within a design science approach. Three instruments serve as base models: NIST SP 800-41 Revision 1, PCI DSS v4.0 Requirements 1 and 7, and a published banking risk framework. Implementation follows a five-input pipeline, and where self-reports and documents disagree, the lower value is used. Validation combines an expert panel, the Delphi technique, scenario-based testing, and benchmark comparison. The design yields three falsifiable benchmarking tests: coverage completeness, measurement extension, and contextual adaptation. It also traces every firewall and NAC dimension to a documented requirement, and it turns the integration claim into a testable interaction term. The study concludes that a security evaluation framework can be designed to fail visibly. As a result, its eventual findings will be meaningful whether they are positive or negative.
Read more