Loading...
Loading...
African Journal of Agriculture and Food Science
Vol. 9Issue 32026pp. 93–110Published 13 November 2026
DOI 10.52589/AJAFS-NPBIGMSystematic Review
Share Link
Cite this
Citation unavailable for this article.
Abstract:
Background: Climate variability constrains smallholder rice production through liquidity shortages, input-risk exposure, insurance gaps and delayed investment. Climate-responsive financing (CRF) is promoted as a bridge between financial access and climate-smart agriculture (CSA), yet empirical studies often combine climate-specific finance with ordinary agricultural credit. Objective: To determine what empirical evidence exists on the effects of CRF on rice productivity and net farm income among smallholder farmers in Tanzania, and whether CSA has been demonstrated, rather than assumed, to mediate those effects. Methods: The review follows PRISMA 2020, PRISMA-S and the Synthesis Without Meta-analysis (SWiM) guideline. Eligibility was defined with a PECO framework and explicit operational definitions of smallholder farmers, CRF, rice-specific outcomes and net farm income. Studies were classified as core CRF evidence, adjacent agricultural-finance evidence or comparative mechanism evidence using pre-specified decision rules. Risk of bias was assessed with RoB 2 and ROBINS-I, and certainty with GRADE. Mediation evidence was classified using a single three-category scheme. The original database exports could not be reconstructed; the earlier project search log is therefore disclosed as a limitation and is not reported as audited PRISMA flow statistics. Results: Nine empirical studies, each checked against its publisher record during manuscript preparation, were synthesised: six from Tanzania and three comparative studies from Kenya and Nigeria. None met the full core CRF definition for Tanzanian rice. A randomised Tanzanian microcredit study found no overall increase in paddy yield, rice profit or household income. Studies of village savings and lending associations and an agricultural credit guarantee scheme reported positive productivity and profitability effects, with moderate risk of residual selection. A national Tanzanian study found CSA adoption associated with crop yield and farm income. Tanzanian index-insurance evidence concerns demand rather than productivity. No study demonstrated CRF-to-CSA-to-income mediation; the evidence is classified as pathway-consistent. Conclusion: Financial instruments can affect rice productivity and profitability under particular institutional and agro-ecological conditions, but climate-labelled financing and formal mediation evidence remain underdeveloped in Tanzania. Multi-season designs that link climate-labelled financing to measured CSA adoption and net income are the clearest research priority.
Disclaimer/Publisher’s Note
The statements, opinions and data contained in this publication are solely those of the author(s) and contributor(s) and not of AB Journals or its editors. AB Journals remains neutral and accepts no responsibility for any injury or damage resulting from ideas, methods, instructions or products referred to in the content.
Copyrights