Editor ID *

Article Title *

Article ID *

.

[1] Topic Clearly Describe the Article
(4) Excellent(3) Good(2) Fair(1) Poor

[2] Content Quality and Originality
(4) Excellent(3) Good(2) Fair(1) Poor

[3] Relevant to the Theme of the Journal
(4) Excellent(3) Good(2) Fair(1) Poor

[4] Relevant Introduction and Sufficient Descriptive of Content
(4) Excellent(3) Good(2) Fair(1) Poor

[5] Accuracy of Results and Validity of Methodology
(4) Excellent(3) Good(2) Fair(1) Poor

[6] Appropriateness of Literature Review
(4) Excellent(3) Good(2) Fair(1) Poor

[7] Clarity of Tables and Figures in Relevant to Comprehension of Text
(4) Excellent(3) Good(2) Fair(1) Poor

[8] Discussion and Conclusion
(4) Excellent(3) Good(2) Fair(1) Poor

[9] Relevant and Completeness of Reference List
(4) Excellent(3) Good(2) Fair(1) Poor

[10] Relevance of Manuscript to the Readers and Contribution to Knowledge
(4) Excellent(3) Good(2) Fair(1) Poor

Your Comments

Decision *
(1) Accept submission, no revisions required(2) Accept submission, revisions required; please revise the paper according to comments(3) Reject, but encourage author(s) to try major revision and re-submit(4) Reject, do not encourage a rewrite

File Upload

Δ